A few years ago I made this Halloween Album. I put it out in October for all to look through. We love seeing the kids over the years and their costume choices at different ages. There are even some old pics of Mom & Dad in costume.
a Ninja and a dark Princess
Garden theme: beekeeper, baby bee, flower, ladybug
baseball player and a mouse, counting their candy!
fairy princess and scary skeleton
mean girls mouse, 50's carhop and Barbie!
My Little Ponies (remember them?) with dad and mom
ponies and the curious kitten
awesome scarecrow and pregnant bee
toy soldier and sad clown
Keep it simple. Use a few photos that show their costumes and personality. Maybe a shot of the jack-o-lanterns they carved, or your front door decorations. Easy cropping, add the year and a line or two about the night. No page protectors needed.